Skip to content

Best hotels in New York City

Ranked by Frog Score: rooms, service, location, design, amenities, coolness and value, each scored 1-10 by our editors.

  1. The Arlo Midtown hotel tower seen from the streetArlo Midtown–Boutique hotel · Midtown ManhattanA Midtown hotel with room and suite categories, dining and a rooftop venue.
  2. Arlo SoHo–Compact-room lifestyle hotel · $$ · SoHoA Hudson Square hotel with 325 small, efficient rooms, a courtyard and a rooftop with Hudson River views.
  3. Crosby Street Hotel–Luxury boutique hotel · $$$$ · SoHoA Firmdale boutique hotel on a cobbled SoHo street, with Kit Kemp interiors, 86 rooms and suites, a bar and a private garden.
  4. Hotel Beacon's Broadway facade and lit entrance at duskHotel Beacon–Apartment-style hotel · Upper West SideA 1928 Beaux-Arts hotel on Broadway beside the Beacon Theatre, with kitchenettes in its rooms and suites and no resort fee.
  5. Hotel Indigo Lower East Side–Boutique tower hotel · $$ · Lower East SideA 294-room Lower East Side tower on Ludlow Street, with a rooftop restaurant and bar and a pool.
  6. Moxy NYC East Village–Lifestyle hotel · $$ · East VillageA 286-room Marriott Moxy on East 11th Street, with Tao Group restaurants and bars including a year-round rooftop.
  7. Pod Brooklyn–Compact-room hotel · WilliamsburgA Williamsburg hotel offering compact private rooms, including queen and bunk configurations.
  8. Renaissance New York Harlem Hotel–Full-service hotel · HarlemA Marriott Renaissance on West 125th Street, with design nods to Harlem's arts history and express subways to Midtown.
  9. Romer Hell's Kitchen–Boutique hotel · Hell's KitchenAn Eighth Avenue boutique hotel a few blocks from Times Square, with a café, a lobby study and a speakeasy cocktail bar.
  10. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel–Landmark luxury hotel · $$$$ · Upper East SideThe Upper East Side's grand hotel since 1930, home to Bemelmans Bar, with rooms that feel like a private apartment.
  11. The Evelyn–Historic mid-range hotel · $$ · Flatiron & NoMadA historic NoMad hotel on East 27th Street, a short walk from Madison Square Park and the Empire State Building.
  12. The High Line Hotel–Historic boutique hotel · $$$ · ChelseaAn 1895 red-brick former seminary building in Chelsea, with large rooms and a front garden that works as a neighborhood café.
  13. The ornate brownstone facade of The Lucerne Hotel on the Upper West SideThe Lucerne Hotel–Boutique hotel · Upper West SideAn Upper West Side hotel in a building dating to 1904.
  14. The Marlton Hotel's brick-and-stone facade and entrance canopy at duskThe Marlton Hotel–Boutique hotel · Greenwich VillageA small-room boutique hotel on West 8th Street between Fifth and Sixth Avenues, with its own restaurant, Chez Nous.
  15. The Plaza's facade and green roof seen across the trees of Central ParkThe Plaza–Luxury hotel · Midtown ManhattanThe Fifth Avenue landmark at Central Park South, open since 1907, with 282 rooms and afternoon tea in the Palm Court.
  16. The Wall Street Hotel–Luxury hotel · $$$$ · Financial DistrictA 180-room luxury hotel at 88 Wall Street, with harbor views, a private rooftop terrace and John Fraser's restaurant La Marchande.
  17. The Whitby Hotel–Midtown design hotel · Midtown ManhattanA Firmdale hotel on West 56th Street with individually designed rooms and suites, plus a bar and restaurant.
  18. The Washington Square Hotel's facade and entrance on Waverly PlaceWashington Square Hotel–Neighborhood hotel · Greenwich VillageA Greenwich Village hotel at Waverly Place and MacDougal Street.
  19. A Wythe Hotel guest room with armchairs and a wall of factory windows facing the Manhattan skylineWythe Hotel–Boutique hotel · WilliamsburgA 69-room Williamsburg hotel in a converted 1901 cooperage, with the Le Crocodile brasserie and Bar Blondeau.